Asphalt driveway paving typically costs $5-8 per square foot in Middle Island, NY, while paver driveways range from $17-20 per square foot. Your final cost depends on size, site preparation needs, and material choices.A standard two-car driveway (20×40 feet) runs $4,000-6,400 for asphalt or $13,600-16,000 for pavers. These prices include proper excavation, base preparation, and installation—not just surface material. Beware driveway contractors who quote significantly lower—they’re usually cutting corners on foundation work that ensures longevity.We provide detailed written estimates that break down every cost so you understand exactly what you’re getting.